Unlike the book, the film version of Prince Caspian is better in almost every way than its predecessor. Director Andrew Adamson, who clearly struggled with The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, seems to have found his footing on the second Narnia movie, which is a more consistent experience. Nearly every aspect of the movie has improved, including the action, music, cinematography, pacing and humor.
It helps that the book lends itself to film more than the first. A larger and more action-packed story than Wardrobe, Prince Caspian picks up a thousand Narnian years after the first movie, but just a year later in Earth time. The four Pevensie children—who are now effectively adults in children’s bodies—return to Narnia and find that foreign humans have taken control and wiped out most of the land’s native, mythical inhabitants, who now live in hiding. Plus, Aslan is nowhere to be found.
The Pevensies must find a way to meet up with Prince Caspian, whose throne has been usurped by his evil uncle Miraz, and unite the native Narnians to place the rightful king back on the throne and end the land’s oppression.
Everything about Caspian seems more solid this time around, and the film is really only hurt by a few bad performances. Overall the cast does a great job, particularly with the mythical characters. Fans of the chivalrous mouse-warrior Reepicheep should be thrilled with the way the gallant rodent comes to life on screen.
Georgie Henley and Skandar Keynes capture Lucy and Edmund perfectly, as they did in the first movie. Ben Barnes, in his first major role as Prince Caspian, does a decent job and should get at least a few teenage girls to swoon, and Sergio Castellitto steals his scenes as King Miraz. Even Liam Neeson sounds a little less like himself, a little more like Aslan this time around.
The main problem lies with Peter and Susan, portrayed by William Moseley and Anna Popplewell. Just like in Wardrobe, these two just cannot carry leading roles in a movie. Their acting is flat and obvious, and every scene they’re in, now matter how well crafted, suffers a little.
Thankfully, one of the other problems of the first movie, the deviations from the book, isn’t as big of an issue this time around. It’s not that it doesn’t differ as much—quite the opposite, actually—it’s just that it doesn’t seem to matter. The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe is almost a sacred text to many Christians, so every deviation in the movie felt like a betrayal. With Caspian, I honestly couldn’t even remember enough about the book to spot many of the differences.
Of course, with its streamlined nature, the movie can’t explore as many Christian themes as the novel. However, there are still enough lessons here to delight pastors and youth leaders looking for sermon video clips, particularly on the main theme of faith. Lucy, who has retained her child-like attitude, is the only one who can see Aslan this time, and the rest of the heroes disbelieve her. When they try to win the war without looking to Aslan, everything fails.
In another scene involving temptation, Edmund—who has experienced the most redemption—is the one who sees through the lies. Little tidbits like that make this movie a great tool for parents.
While not on the same quality level as something like The Lord of the Rings, Prince Caspian is a big step forward for the Narnia movies and gives a fans of the C.S. Lewis novels hope for the future of the franchise. Bring on The Voyage of the Dawn Treader!